Is Michael Todd a false teacher?

Category 5

Verdict: Michael Todd preaches the Prosperity and Popularity Gospels. His potential danger is one of Joel Osteen levels.

 

Preface

At the request of one of our readers, we have been asked to investigate whether Michael Todd is a false teacher. You can make a request here, and we will honor it. It is a source of joy to be trusted in such a way. It is most reasonable to have never heard of Priscilla Shirer, but part of what we want to do in our Discernment ministry is to go beyond the low hanging fruits like a Joel Osteen or Paula White.

Background

Michael Todd AKA Mike Todd is a megachurch pastor in Tulsa, Oklahoma. He went viral from his sermon series “Relationship Goals” which he turned into a book and study. He pastors at Transformation Church, a church founded by Gary McIntosh. Michael Todd began as the protégé of Gary McIntosh. Transformations Church bills itself as a “dynamic, multi-ethnic, multi-cultural, non-denominational inner-city ministry in Tulsa, Oklahoma. It embraces the spirit of its founder as it expresses a radical, diversified, progressive, 21st century technological church.” The fact that they use the word progressive in their church description is foreshadowing what’s to come.

Transformation Church

Is Transformation Church a legitimate church? Let’s perform the website test. Transformation Church lists their statement of faith which contains sixteen pillars. The ministry positions considered valid according to Transformation Church are:

THE FIVE-FOLD MINISTRY POSITIONS OF APOSTLES, PROPHETS, EVANGELISTS, PASTORS, AND TEACHERS ARE GIFTS GIVEN TO EACH LOCAL CHURCH AND THE UNIVERSAL CHURCH. THESE GIFTS ARE FOR THE EQUIPPING OF BELIEVERS TO SPREAD THE GOSPEL OF CHRIST. WE BELIEVE BOTH MEN AND WOMEN ARE SOVEREIGNLY CHOSEN BY GOD FOR THESE MINISTRY POSITIONS.

At a minimum, its unbiblical to exclude deacons as a ministry position. It’s absolutely arrogant to elevate oneself to prophet or apostle. The title is void of meaning, in doing so. Furthermore, churches that proclaim such titles usually bend on more passages. The statement of faith goes on to insert the Prosperity Gospel. We bolded the text that in no way support their following claims.

WE BELIEVE THAT, AS PART OF CHRIST’S WORK OF SALVATION, IT IS THE FATHER’S WILL FOR BELIEVERS TO BECOME WHOLE, HEALTHY, AND SUCCESSFUL IN ALL AREAS OF LIFE:

  1. SPIRITUAL

(John 3:3, 11: Romans 10:9-10, 2 Corinthians 5:17-21)

  1. MENTAL & EMOTIONAL

(Isaiah 26:3; 2 Timothy 1:7; Romans 12:2)[1]

  1. PHYSICAL

(Isaiah 53:4,5; Matthew 8:17; 1 Peter 2:24)[2]

  1. FINANCIAL

(Deuteronomy 28:1-14; Joshua 1:8; Psalm 34:10, 84:11; Malachi 3:10)[3]

The statement of faith inserts the Prosperity Gospel as well as some NAR language. This is enough to not recommend this church at a minimum. It’s is also safe to assume that the Prosperity Gospel is preached there. Transformation Church also ordains female ministers. We would not consider Transformation Church to be a legitimate local church.

It’s worth noting that Transformation Church has a robust YouTube page which boasts both the influence and the need for discernment.

Popularity Gospel

The supposedly famous “Relationship Goals” series which went “viral” according to Transformation Church is littered with the self-love Popularity Gospel which looks to make people feel good rather than be confronted with the realities present in a Christian worldview.

In part two[4] of the endless series, Michael Todd inserts a commandment in Matthew 22. For reference:

36“Teacher, which is the great commandment in the Law?” 37And He said to him, “‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ 38This is the great and foremost commandment. 39The second is like it, ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ 40On these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets.”

Michael Todd preaches that loving your neighbor as yourself is conditioned upon loving one’s self. This unbiblical insertion into this passage ignores human nature preestablished in Scripture that Jesus is referencing. According to the Bible, self-love is assumed. Therefore, Jesus has no need to preach on self-esteem. Self-love is assumed because we are inherently selfish and sinful because of our nature.[5] Yet Michael Todd uses this passage to say that we need to love ourselves. If anything, this passage is not about loving ourselves. Love your neighbor as you love yourself is far easier if we take ourselves down a few notches. It’s about loving yourself less not more and loving other people more. He goes on to say your love for Jesus should be equal to your self love. This is an anti-biblical message meant to tickle people’s ears. The easiest message to hear is you need to love yourself.

To the loneliest generation, Michael Todd preaches that singleness is the most important time in one’s life.[6] This ignores the long human history of there not being a gap between youth and adulthood. But prolonged adolescence is good for growth because human nature is somehow different in the twenty-first century than in any other. Another note on these sermons is that they are eisegesis in action. He is making his relationship points and occasionally finding Scripture that backs his point. And a lot of his points are not biblical like the singleness passage above and some simply aren’t remotely profound ie dating not wrong if God is in the middle. And for the most part throughout my observations, he relies on paraphrased translations of the Bible and sometimes whatever The Message counts as. In Part eight of this sermon series, he claims we should end relationships that slow us down. This could easily be construed as getting rid of “negativity” in your life, a very secular mindset.[7] His messages are meant to make people feel good and contain little biblical substance.

Association With False Teachers

In 2019, Michael Todd was a headline speaker at Lakewood Church’s Hope & Life Conference. This is just the cumulation of the well-established link between Michael Todd and Joel Osteen. If Michael Todd is this in bed with Joel Osteen, it would be because he does not preach the true gospel.

Image

In addition to Lakewood Church, he has also preached at Steve Furtick’s Elevation Church. He is widely recognized to be a false teacher by ally publications.[8] He also spoke at Vous Church in Florida where Rich Wilkerson Jr preaches.[9] On a more topical note, Michael Todd is one of the preachers that rushed to surround Kanye West following his actual? conversion.[10]

 

Conclusion

After surveying his sermons online, it’s clear that Michael Todd’s ideas are neither profound nor is his exegesis admirable, intellectually stimulating, or otherwise not found on an Instagram post. Aside from taking the reins in a megachurch, the only reason he has achieved the popularity as he’s accumulated is because he sounds like Kevin Hart while preaching the Popularity Gospel and the Prosperity Gospel. Thus, his potential danger of Michael Todd is as the next Joel Osteen.

We rate Michael Todd a Category Five for his associations because the evidence shown denotes that he preaches a counterfeit gospel, one of self-love and personal gain.

 


[1] There is some validity to the Holy Spirit renewing our minds, but this does not mean we are immune to mental health issues. 2 Timothy 1:7 does not support this claim.

[2] These three passages are all in reference to Jesus, not the followers of Jesus. Jesus was foretold to perform the miracles of healing. This is not a promise for his followers. After all, many of those healed or did not hear the Word. None of these passages in context support this claim.

[3] The passage in Deuteronomy 28 is about the Protestant work ethic as it’s called. Transformation Church assumes that “make your way prosperous” refers to our estate rather than “way” as when early Christians were called followers of The Way. Psalm 34:10 is about the Lord providing daily, not becoming wealthy. The context of the Malachi passage is tithing.

[4] Single, Not Alone: Relationship Goals (Part 2) Aug 14, 2017 Time stamp 13:00-16:00, 20:45-21:10

[5] Genesis 3. Adam and Eve wanted to be like God in rebellion. Human nature has been selfish ever since.

[6] The Myth Of Dating Relationship Goals (Part 3) Aug 21, 2017 Time Stamp 5:30-6:00

[7] Does “It” Need to End? Relationship Goals (Part 8) Sep 25, 2017

[8] Short list of evidence of Steve Furtick on Pirate Christian. We may do our own verdict on Furtick.

[9] We covered Rich Wilkerson Jr. in a previous article where he gave a sermon at Kanye West’s Sunday Service before Kanye West said he was saved. In this sermon, the Popularity Gospel was preached.

[10] Kanye West’s association with false teachers is reason to remain skeptical. However, baby Christians are very susceptible to false teachers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s