Chris Rosebrough was an earlier discernment blogger and YouTuber who built a name for himself exclusively by going after low-hanging fruit like Joel Osteen and Steven Furtick. He has since branched out and tried his hand in the political arena going after Christian Nationalists and those adjacent to them, to embarrassing results. Not only did he participate in a slander campaign to malign Ryan Turnipseed, he would also affirm Lutheran leadership in their compromises, pointed out at the time. In otherwords, he has become a regime hack.
Now he’s accusing JD Hall, a prolific full time writer and founder of Pulpit and Pen, Protestia, and now Incite To Insight, of plagiarizing AI.Â
I picked a random article from Jordan Hall's Substack, Insight to Incite, and ran it through an AI Detector. Here is what it found: pic.twitter.com/53NMqLDJyt
— Chris Rosebrough (@piratechristian) January 23, 2026
According to an AI detector, run by Grammarly, an AI writer, JD Hall is guilty of resembling AI text. AI is trained by human writings, meaning that the robots will inevitably resemble humans and then the humans being trained to write via AI will create a feedback loop. It’s possible in 2026, the AI detector can hardly tell the difference, whereas a human can listen to a YouTube video and detect an AI script. Having read JD Hall, granted he writes more than I can read, it’s not AI, at least not any AI I’ve ever read. How am I a better judge? Because a robot can hardly tell what is “natural sounding.”
Also consider that Grammarly is using an AI detector to sell their services to make the writing appear less robotic.
Lastly, AI cannot be plagiarized because it’s not human and it’s generally not published. If I use Grok to research an article. The prompt and response are unpublished, so an AI tracker, or plagiarism tracker, is merely guessing.
Chris Rosebrough is stretching hard by wielding false allegations using technology he does not comprehend.
2 Responses
You don’t need an AI detector to tell he uses AI to write most of his articles. See the first line of this.
https://web.archive.org/web/20260105125417/https://insighttoincite.substack.com/p/the-noticing-of-nigeria-and-dead
Oh no! He used a rhetorical device.