Christian News By Christians, For Christians.

Antioch Declaration

When the Moscow Mood Goes Anti-White

If anything, No Quarter November has been rather nonexistent in 2026. In previous years, the Doug Wilson camp literally burned bridges, and the patriarch himself white knighted for female leadership. Halfway into the month, this year’s Moscow Mood finally emerged, and it was in support of the proposition nation.

Comments primarily came from Gabe Rench, “the Waterboy,” who carries water for Wilson’s bad takes. Rench made the comment that “Whiteness did not build America. Color of skin can’t build things.” His premise is that it was not white people, but Christians. While Christianity played a moral component, so too did race. If you take away the Indians, America still exists. Take away the slaves, America still exists, and with far less crime and welfare abuse. America’s legal systems come from the extensive European legal tradition, which would not exist without white people. English is the de facto language. The innovations that enabled the frontier to be tamed were invented by white people. Take away white people, and America does not exist. America is a white country. This is a self-evident truth.

Modern Christianity wants faith to overcome ontological differences between races, and this is just not the case. As the Westminster Confession states, Scripture exists because creation alone is “not sufficient to give that knowledge of God, and of his will, which is necessary unto salvation.” (Westminster 1.1). Christianity will solve many spiritual problems, but it will not make a nation prosperous if the nation lacks the means to be prosperous. The bible does not teach people how to farm, nor is it a science textbook. Scripture does not provide knowledge on how to create nuclear energy or extract oil from the ground. Scripture was not the means by which the Wright Brothers invented flight. This is not complicated. Pagan Rome was an advanced civilization whose achievements were unrivaled until the Renaissance. The Roman Pantheon is a geometric masterpiece, and their aqueducts, roads, bridges, concrete, and other inventions have stood the test of time. Just as there is no separating the greatness of Rome from the Roman people, there is no separating the greatness of America from white Europeans who built a nation from nothing.

The Waterboy then tried to make sectarian distinctions between Protestants and Catholics by blaming Roman Catholicism for Mexico and Brazil while touting Protestantism for America.

Andrew Torba rightfully points out that Liberia has a mirror version of our constitution while being predominantly Protestant, yet is a third-world country descended from the slaves who were sent back to Africa. Rench posits that Catholic theology inhibited Catholics from creating an America, using Mexico and Brazil as his examples, but ignores the non-white demographics of those countries. Mexicans are still very much descended from the savage Aztecs, while Brazil was the largest slave importer in the New World. Demographics determined the destiny of those countries, not as much theology. If anything, French Catholic Quebec is a better comparison to America because more shared ancestry. While there are differences, Quebec is still First World. Liberia might have better theology, but it is still a vastly inferior place to live than Quebec.

Carrying water for Rench was CREC President Uriesou Brito, who is Brazilian, in his response to Torba’s tweet:

What a shallow argument! The Christian faith is not some magical formula that automatically produces clean streets or even economic prosperity… or political stability. Every nation has a story. And every nation has its wars and institutional failures that cannot be reduced to religious demographics/geography. And Liberia’s constitutional similarities to America hardly make their systems identical. By this logic, we could photograph the worst neighborhoods in any Western nation and declare Christianity a failure. This is not serious political theology. It’s sociology via Instagram

But what if the demographics are the problem? Despite claiming to be majority Christian, Haiti is, as President Trump famously described, a “shit-hole” because of the Haitians. Dumping obscene amounts of money into missional tourism will not change that. Brito has the gall to equivocate third-world slums to the “worst neighborhoods in any Western nation” but ignores the obvious fact that the worst neighborhoods in America are so because of black or Hispanic crime. Again, evidence that demographics caused the decline of cities in America built by the descendants of white Europeans.

Ironically, these people will claim to be Conservative and Rench even voted for Donald Trump, whose slogan was Make America Great Again. The beauty of MAGA as a slogan is that it acknowledges America’s decline, making it intrinsically anti-progressive. The two central issues associated with MAGA were immigration and globalization. In other words, demographics led to America’s decline. This is what the American people voted for in 2016 and in 2024 with overt support for mass deportations.

The Moscow Mood’s embrace of the Proposition Nation is fairly unsurprising. They have long slapped “covenant” in front of nation to posit the nation as a covenant, which is a proposition with extra steps that few people agree to. This is the same tactic woke pastors did by slapping “kingdom” in front of terms like “diversity” to Christianize anti-white ideas. Of the many central problems with the Proposition Nation is the proposition they ascribe to America is one the Founding Fathers did not believe. Toby Sumpter defined a nation as a covenanted people, but this ignores the consanguineous nature of a nation. Moscow simply replaces proposition with a covenant and applies the same liberal principles that mere adherence or subscription to the covenant incorporates one into the nation. The nation is the covenant people one chooses but is something one is born into. The American founding, both in the Declaration and the Constitution, appeals to shared blood, so too did Washington, Jefferson, and the Federalist Papers (see John Jay’s Federalist 2).

This is Blank Slate Biblicism. Differences between group outcomes are attributed to theology, not natural distinctions between groups. The slaves and Indians could have built America if they just had the Bible. Bad theology is the only barrier stopping Africa from achieving Wakanda. Blank Slate Biblicism embraces Rousseau’s Noble Savage, that inside every Iraqi is a freedom-loving covenantal American if they just embraced the Westminster Divines. The covenant is just another version of Social Contract. Ignore the enumerated fact that America was founded by a distinct people for the posterity of that people, not the whole world, if they affirm some undefined covenant.

Not every problem in this world is one of theology. Not every revelation is special revelation. Faith is fundamental to the nation, but so too is the ethnic composition. This is the same debate as Alan Strange had with Stephen Wolfe on the superiority of nations.

The liberal cannot acknowledge such a possibility despite demonstrable proof because he would conclude the superiority of white nations over non-white. Thus, all nations must be equal, perhaps even interchangeable. Moscow takes the halfway position, attributing the success of nations to theology and covenant rather than acknowledging that racial differences produce different outcomes regardless of theology.

Receive the Evangelical Dark Web Newsletter

Get Christian news in your inbox. Sign up and receive a free copy of Winning Not Winsome.

Support the Evangelical Dark Web

By becoming a member of Evangelical Dark Web, you get access to more content, help drive the direction of our research, and support the operations of the ministry.
Facebook
Twitter
Telegram
Reddit
LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Receive the Evangelical Dark Web Newsletter

Get Christian news in your inbox. Sign up and receive a free copy of Winning Not Winsome.
Join 10015 other subscribers

Trending Posts