A third of Trump’s 2024 voters did not come back in 2026. Quantus Insights posted the chart. The method is not theirs, and the cause is the Iran War. Of every 100 Trump 2024 voters, about 63 voted Republican, 4 voted Democratic, and 33 stayed home. Of every 100 Harris voters, about 85 voted Democratic. Very few switched, despite the hype. A third of one side sat out.
The source line on the graphic is Lenny Bronner of Broome Street Labs, precinct results in 11 states, Harris figures rounded. Jason Corley, Quantus’s co-founder and lead pollster, published the same breakdown the day before the thread. Bronner infers individual behavior from precinct totals. He is not holding a voter file. Corley says as much. People misremember how they voted two years ago, and a precinct model is still a model. The gray bar is labeled “did not vote or went third party.” Corley says eight of every nine Trump voters who did not vote Republican simply did not vote.
Three efforts land in the same place. J.L. Partners, an Election Day poll on top of more than 30,000 campaign interviews, split a roughly 15-point national swing into 10 points of turnout and 5 of switching. Their cut is that 35 percent of Trump’s 2024 voters skipped, against 22 percent of Harris voters. Bronner puts it near 75 percent turnout and 20 percent switching. The exit polls allow more switching, around 35 percent, and still have turnout in front. J.L. Partners ran the counterfactual. Republicans lose both chambers with zero switching.
The sit-out was the core, not the edge. Among Trump’s 2024 voters, 46 percent without a college degree skipped, 46 percent of Hispanics, 44 percent of those 65 and older, and 39 percent of the rural. White evangelicals fell from 23 percent of the electorate to 17. Corley’s line is the one Hibbs and Hamrick will not say. Nobody was persuaded of anything there. They were persuaded not to vote.
The raw votes match the model. Hyde-Smith finished nearly 300,000 votes behind Trump in Mississippi. Hinson ran almost 300,000 behind him in Iowa. Texas is the exception Bronner flags, the one state where switching explains more of the Democratic gain than turnout. Paxton still fell 2.1 million short of Trump. Democrats took a 56-44 Senate and the House popular vote by 14 points. Turnout was high, near 49 percent of eligible voters. It was high on one side.
Corley names the motive and leaves it on the table. The two promises that built the 2024 coalition were lower prices and no new wars. Trump launched the Iran War with Israel on February 28, said it would last four weeks or so, and eight months later the Strait was still a weapon and diesel was still a tax. Sixty-three percent of voters called the military action the wrong decision. About three-quarters said it was a crucial or major factor. The economy was the top issue because the war did its damage at the pump. Fifty-two percent still viewed Democrats unfavorably on the day they handed them Congress. Democrats did not win a mandate. They won an empty chair.
Vance looked at a different cut and talked himself out of the obvious. He wrote that the main problem was not turnout, that Trump/Vance voters showed up and voted Democratic, and that the defectors wanted the war ended, prices down, America First, and a different relationship with Israel. “The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so.” The four demands are right. The mechanism is wrong. Four out of a hundred crossed over. Thirty-three did not come back. Florida, where the electorate was only a couple points off 2024, is not Mississippi.
Harris’s people took the field. Trump’s did not, because the man they elected to keep them out of a Middle East war started one and sent them the bill at the gas station. They were not stolen. They were not converted. They sat out a betrayal.




