Will Spencer is a failed Manosphere blogger, who was once astroturfed on Mid Eva podcasts as a Christian alternative to Andrew Tate. This ended disastrously. Nevertheless, he still did appearances on the Jeremy Boreing Podcast and now a Disputatio at New Saint Andrews College in Moscow, Idaho. The discourse captured a live tension inside the world Doug Wilson built. Will Spencer delivered an address on fatherlessness, shame, isolation, and the “blame ladder” that he said can slide young Christian men from grievance into conspiracy theories, antisemitism, and White nationalism. He contrasted that path with Christian sonship: repentance, responsibility, and love of neighbor.
Then a student, Jonathan Adams, stepped to the microphone around the 48-minute mark and asked whether Spencer would repent for amplifying Erick Erickson’s articles that grouped Jack Posobiec, William Wolfe, JD Vance, the Claremont Institute, American Reformer, and American Moment among others as racist, antisemitic subversives. Adams called those men “absolute patriots” and effective workers in conservative institutions. Spencer did not repent. He defended sharing Erickson’s work as information-gathering even if some details might be off. William Wolfe later praised the student for holding “dangerous slander” to account.
That exchange sits inside a larger split. In late 2024 Wilson helped draft and promote the Antioch Declaration, a statement invoking Paul’s confrontation of Peter at Antioch. It denounced pattern recognition as it relates to Jewish behavior being a unique threat to Christianity and the west. The Declaration was stated to have the intent to assist Pete Hegseth in confirmation hearings, which undermined it theological veracity with dated political horsetrading.
Yet the culture Wilson’s institutions actually produce, the “Moscow Mood” of pugilistic humor, classical education, postmillennial confidence, and no-quarter cultural combat, has continued to attract and form young men who treat the Declaration more as a remote document than a binding local ethic.
The Moscow Mood, in practice, has shown more affinity for the energy, aesthetics, and personnel of those circles than for the Declaration’s caution. Students formed inside NSA’s Disputatio tradition, Logos School, and Christ Church’s orbit are absorbing the combative posture Wilson models online while treating his signed statements as one more item to debate rather than obey.
Wilson himself operates on two registers. Online and in print he is dogmatic, prolific, and willing to draw bright lines. In his own backyard he functions more like a grandfather who built the house and then lets the grandkids argue in it. Disputatio exists precisely so students can question invited speakers in public. The college and church have long practiced a style that prizes rhetoric, pushback, and the formation of young men who will not be easily cowed. That local allowance is why Adams could stand up, name names, and demand repentance without being shut down. The same ecosystem that produced the Antioch Declaration also produced the student who treated its spirit as slander when applied to men he regards as allies. Wilson’s institutions reward the fight even when the fight is aimed at positions he has publicly endorsed.
The result is that the students in Moscow look all right. They are not drifting left. They are not abandoning the project of Christian cultural engagement. They are not selling out for trips to Israel. They are refusing to treat Erickson-style lists or Spencer’s “blame ladder” as the last word on who counts as a dangerous radical versus a useful patriot. They live inside Wilson’s world and have decided the Antioch Declaration does not bind their loyalties the way the Moscow Mood does. Whether that is healthy formation or the predictable outcome of training young men to fight first and parse later is the question the event itself raised.
Does a grandfatherly allowance of debate in Moscow ultimately strengthen Wilson’s project, or does it guarantee that the next generation will keep the mood and discard the declarations?
Powered by RedCircle
